An observation......for simplicity and to reiterate what most of the early discussion focused on
You guys are certainly doing a good job with the investigation but, as said earlier, I think we're getting bogged down a bit in the complexities of MPPT, diodes etc...which is fine but doesn't really help sorting out the more basic requirement of most who are looking to set up a good 12v chárging system. I'm concerned that confusion will result.
- Most solar panels now come with blocking diodes
- A portable panel, to supplement the standard roof panels, must have its own separate controller and be wired directly to the battery
- Attach regulators as close to the battery as possible
- Keep the wiring to the best possible size..6 or 8
- Keep the portable panel cable as short as possible, within the range needed...10m is possible if the cable size is correct
- Regulator must be able to cope with panel specs...at least 20 amps, preferably 30
- Regulator can be MPPT for optimum results but a PWM is adequate for most occasions. MPPT is superior, but most of the others are OK for basic requirements
- Keep panels clean
- Know your power requirements and charging and battery capacity before overspending
- KISS
I know many of us have been using good 12v systems for many years by following basic principles ...in our case for over 20 years....and I know if I'd stumbled on this very complicated discussion, needing some simple advice on solar charging, I'd run a mile!
You are pretty right on that @Dobbie . The trouble is that technology is ALWAYS on the move and improving all the time. 20 years ago, I doubt anyone had even heard of MPPT controllers, let alone much choice or info on standard PWM type controllers. @Moto Mech said " a little knowledge is dangerous" and it is too. If you do not want to get into trouble, stick to the simple things that you know, but that way you do not keep up with the latest in technology and miss out on chances to improve your system. The other alternative if you are not too sure is to ACTIVELY seek advice and there is certainly no shortage of that on this forum. It is still up to the individual as to where they want to be. And I do not think you would have "run a mile" back then if the more technical information available was simply explained to you. Could I be right about this?
Notwithstanding what I have said above, it is good to be reminded that a lot of members may not have any , or only limited tech knowledge, to be interested in a lot of technical jargon and that you are moderating on their behalf. Cheers
Note: IMHO, line 2 is not correct. A portable solar panel CAN be connected without its own controller IF it is connected in PARALLEL with roof top panels. Understandably, one would need to have an Anderson plug on side of van (to plug in portable panel) and have that wired in PARALLEL with the other input wires from roof panels. This eliminates need for separate controller, although one would have to bypass the controller on back of portable panel AND make sure blocking diodes were in place. The other problem then is that the portable panel is restricted to just being plugged into van Anderson plug and loses versatility of separate use for other purposes unless controller is back in circuit. Probably TOO complex for a lot, but still possible!! Technology is tough stuff for some.
Last edited: