Myself I would rather individual systems for proper off grid, these things have one little failure and everything drops off, great having failsafe's of course but if something has a hissy, it can shut the whole shebang down, fridge, lights, pump, dunny, charging everything............. at least with mine even if the solar dies I can simply change the load and still have 12v feed and a portable panel/controller as back up or use genny............
Hi
@Drover,
I am always in two minds with this issue.
Take cars, I loved the "gold old days" of motoring when one could fix everything on a car. Each bit replaceable and not a huge effort or cost to do it.
But in those days, cars were serviced every 1,600kms, and many bits needed to be replaced: timing gears, oil seals, king pins, spark plugs, points, coils, fan belts, head gaskets, welsh plugs, rust, wheel bearings. Even engine replacements were common enough that Repco provided short, long exchanges.
Roll on and everything is controlled by an ICU. That is indeed worrying for me. But, the flip side is that there is almost nothing one can carry that will help when you break down since, given regular maintenance, the most important part, the ICU, is not really practical to carry as a spare.
So other than a tool box, the only thing I consider a necessity nowadays is to keep my RACV Total Care up to date and the phone number in the glove box.
So it is with the Setec, BmPro, Projecta BMS evolution. Most issues with the Setec, are related to patching together a variety extras necessary due to the changing requirements of campers and equipment. In comparison to these issues, there are relatively few failures of the Setec Unit itself.
Hopefully, the Projecta is a small positive step forward in having a better Battery management system incorporating the tug, solar, 240V, the van battery (in all its variants) and the 12V requirements of the van.
Still missing are provision of 240V off grid, automatic switch over of all power points from pole power to inverter, and generator autostart.
Only time will tell if the Projecta can supply these improved features in a manageable way with increased reliability.
As
@Boots in Action alluded to in an earlier post, it needs to be done without increased complexity for users who are mainly interested in camping and not having to become power engineers to power the van off-grid.
take care
Mike